Grammar/Punctuation Challenge
Instructions:
1. | Read the following letter all the way through at your normal rate, without regard for errors it may contain. |
2. | Read it again, this time checking for grammar and punctuation. |
3. | If you find an error, circle it, then use the righthand column to state as best you can (with or without technical terms of grammar) the nature of the error. |
4. | Stop at the line after paragraph 6 until you meet with a tutor and he or she asks you to continue. |
Dear Freshman, 1. It seems like only yesterday when I was sitting in your places, wanting to make the best possible use of the time, which remained of my college years. I made some good decisions and others were problematic. 2. Now that I am a full-fledged, working CPA, Dean Parker, whom I owe some favors, has called me, and asked me to take a few minutes to reflect on the skills that I wish I had developed in my college years'. (She successfully flattered me by saying that she knew that any response of mine would, in her words,"be honest and substantive.) 3. When I first heard Dean Parkers request I had no idea what I might write to you about, but then it came to me (naturally enough), when I sat down to do the writing: writing was the skill I ought
to have learned
better in school! |
4. I am not surprised by my former classmates, when they tell me how much writing they have to do on the job, they however are people who went into fields like law, marketing, and advertising. I did not go into such a field—or so I thought. In fact, I chose accounting partly to escape words. 5. Little did I know that even an accountant spends fifty percent of his or her work time writing! Everything from memos and accounting footnotes to shareholder's reports. Needless to say an accountant who can crunch numbers, but cannot state clearly what it means will not do well, clients want something more than the numbers; lucid analysis. They want to know the numbers' meaning for them. For example the profitability of their subdivisions. Or the tax implications of taking certain losses in one year, instead of to wait. What is more to the point, they want to be told these things clearly and concisely, not to be handed vague language or language so rife with grammatical errors as to distract them or undermine their confidence in the analysis generally. (You might be shocked to see what big effects even small mechanical errors have on a readers assessment of a writer and a writers' competence. Confidentially, believe it or not I was once informed by a friend that I had been denied a certain choice job interview on |
the basis of my leter of application in which I had carelessly mixed up "there" and "their".) 6. I have been lucky at the firm of Boswell and Anthony. The reason being that my supervisor there edits my draft of memos, gives me writing handbooks to review, and even tutors me at times. As a result, he and I both feel that I've made progress – or what he kindly calls "progress and a half". However, I cannot stress this enough: with almost any other supervisor, I would now be worrying about keeping my job. When it comes to writing a prospective employee should not expect "on-the-job training"; once again, I have been lucky. Stop here until you are asked
to continue. |
7. Another thing I've learned since leaving school, is that strong writing skills are valuable outside of work also. Last year, my grandfather died, he left me some money and objects in his will, but the most special part of his legacy to me was the inscription in a book on sailing lore. "Dear Joe," he wrote, "By the time you read this, I will be away on the final great sea voyage of this life. I may well not see you ever again, and the thought brings tears to my eyes. 8. I myself produced some tears in reading Grandpa's last few words to me, which included reminiscences of times we shared together, since my childhood. I had never been aware of written words potential private power until that. I mean power that a letter to a friend can have. Or leaving a simple note to one's wife on the fridge. 9. Nor is home the only after-hours sphere of life, where the effective use of words makes a difference. No one is just an employee somewhere and a family member; every individual is also a member of a community, and in that community as it turns out, there is always one issue or another which affect that person directly. 10. Only last night, I attended a town hall meeting on the subject of illegal toxic dumping not far from my home. After the Town Solicitor delivered a brief, noncommittal formal report, the |
Mayor asked, Do any members of the public have comments to make at this time?" At those words, I felt a lump rise in my throat and that I should say something. After all, I had a great deal at stake. 11. I am proud to say that I got up enough courage to speak last night and that my words seemed to break the ice; after I spoke five or six other critics of the Town Solicitor's report did the same. I would not pretend however that my statement made the biggest contribution of the evening, one of my neighbors whose name is Jane Shaw gave a speech that residents of our town will not soon forget. Reading from the back of an envelope (like Abraham Lincoln). Jane cited statistics from the latest research on methane, then said, "Our children's future health is at stake, but this towns officials issue deliberately vague reports containing no true plans for action. Our children's future health is at stake but this town's mayor still accepts large contributions for his next campaign from the very individuals responsible for this great hazard". 12. To conclude, I am not yet as effective as Jane when it comes to writing and speaking, however, thanks to my supervisor's efforts at work (mostly with word choice and organization) I am on my way. Once again, though, I was lucky to find such patience in my supervisor: few like him exist
|
13. Those four years ahead of you at school remain your one best shot at putting your verbal house in order. What is more, your success at getting a job, at keeping a job, at being promoted to a better job, and at positive effects in life beyond your job depend largely on doing just that. Words being the essential medium for most commitments and pursuits in life. 14. Because I did not use my college years to improve my writing, even I still lag behind regarding certain aspects of writing, with all the special help that luck has brought me. (I think, for example, that I may still have some problems with my grammar and punctuation. I just hope you didn't notice any!) 15. All best wishes to you. Sincerely, Joe Petry |
Back to The Items on This Web Site |